How to make big decisions that really matter
Some decisions feel simple.
What shall I have for breakfast? What shall I wear today? Do I reply to that message now or later?
Others feel much more consequential and stressful.
Should I take the promotion? Should I leave the job? Should I move house? Should I end this relationship? Should I start a business? Should I say yes to the opportunity everyone else thinks I would be mad to turn down?
Decision-making is part of everyday life, but big decisions can make even capable, thoughtful people feel completely stuck.
We can become paralysed by the need to get it right. We try to think our way through it. We write lists. We ask people what they think. We imagine the best-case scenario, then immediately the worst. We convince ourselves that one wrong move could ruin everything.
And somewhere in all of that noise, we lose access to the thing we most need: clarity on our own goals.
I don’t think good decision-making is about finding a perfect answer. Most of life does not offer us that.
I think it is about creating the conditions where we can make a grounded, healthy, realistic choice.
The first place to draw on your previous decision-making experience. So before you try to force the next answer, look back.
When have you made good decisions before? What helped you make them? Did you take your time? Did you seek advice from someone wise? Did you wait until the answer felt like a clear yes? Did you listen to your intuition? Did you have a sense of calm, even if the decision was challenging?
And when have you made decisions that did not serve you? What was going on then? Were you stressed? Tired? Under pressure? Trying to please someone else? Reacting to a short-term feeling rather than a long-term truth?
This is not about judging yourself. It is about learning your own decision-making patterns.
For me, the best decisions tend to be the ones I have taken time over. The ones where I have not allowed myself to be rushed by another person, a self-imposed deadline or fear. The ones where I have waited until something felt like a firm yes or a new solution has presented itself when the existing options just aren’t quite fitting the bill.
The less helpful decisions have often come when I have been reactive. When I have wanted to escape discomfort quickly and so taken a decision just to alleviate my short-term stress, rather than thinking about what is most aligned with my long-term goals.
It’s important to ask yourself questions that check this alignment.
Not “Is this role impressive?”
Not “Would other people think I was mad to turn it down?”
Not “Is this what someone successful would do?”
But: “Does this take me closer to my real goals?”
That requires you to know what your goals actually are. Not just career goals, but lifestyle goals too.
Do you want more freedom? More time with your children? More creative space? More stability? More challenge? More rest? More financial security? More autonomy?
A decision can be objectively good and still not be right for you now.
A new job might come with more money, more status and more visibility. But if the cost is your health, your family time, your freedom or your sense of self, then that one “con” deserves proper weight.
So if you do make a pros and cons list, do not just count the points. Ask how much each point matters. Ask how each one feels. Ask what it would actually cost you to live with that choice.
That is particularly true in careers. A bigger opportunity can look like the obvious next step from the outside. But there are seasons of life when the best decision is not to climb faster, but to protect what matters most.
That does not mean we avoid growth. Growth often feels uncomfortable. A meaningful decision can stretch us. But there is a difference between a decision that stretches you and one that takes you further away from the life you are trying to build.
This is where it helps to think about your current self and your future self.
If a decision is only for future you, but brings current you no meaning, joy or connection, it may be hard to sustain. Equally, if a decision only satisfies current you but creates problems for future you, that is important to factor in.
What serves the person you are now and the person you are becoming?
If it’s hard for you to see how this decision may play out in the future than I recommend writing out a decision tree.
Take the decision and write down the main options. Then follow each option a few steps forward.
If I say yes, what might happen? I might love it. I might struggle. It might open another door. It might ask more of me than I can give right now. For each of those outcomes then write down at least two next steps you could take from that position.
If I say no, what might happen? Another better opportunity might come along. I might feel relieved. I might feel disappointed and stay in the job I’m in for another year. I might create space for something better aligned. Again, what would be your next steps for each of these outcomes?
This gets us out of binary thinking.
Our brains often tell us it is this job or nothing, this house or no house, this person or no future relationship, this chance or I will never get another one.
Most of the time, that is not true.
Apart from a small number of truly irreversible situations, most decisions can be adjusted. You can pivot. You can change direction. You can learn from the choice and make another one. That does not make decisions meaningless. They matter. But they may not be as final as your fear is telling you they are.
If you really can’t work out what to do then the wisest thing you can do is delay the decision. Not avoid it. Not ignore it. But consciously decide: “I am not making this decision yet.”
If something has been going round and round in your head for months, your brain may need a break. You might decide that, for the next three months, you are not leaving the job, not moving house, not making the next big leap. You are simply going to focus on enjoying where you are and taking care of yourself, building readiness and creating space to make that decision in future.
That pause can bring relief. And relief often creates clarity. It helps you get over the decision fatigue that may be wearing you out.
You may also be getting too many people's opinions, so it may be time to stop talking about this decision for a few weeks. Everyone brings their own values, fears, hopes and experiences. Sometimes people respond less to your decision and more to what your decision triggers in them.
When you are ready for advice, choose a small number of trusted people. People who know you. People who have your best interests at heart. People who can support you without projecting their own fear onto your life.
Ultimately, better decision-making is not about being perfectly rational or purely intuitive. It is about bringing both together.
Use logic. Write things down. Think through consequences. Ask good questions.
But also listen to the feeling underneath.
Does this feel expansive or heavy? Calm or sticky? Aligned or forced? Is it a clear yes, or are you trying to talk yourself into it because it looks good on paper?
If something does not feel right, ask a better question: “What would feel better?”
So if you are facing a big decision right now, start by answering these questions:
How have I made good decisions in the past and what helped me?
What are my real goals, not just the ones that look impressive?
What would this decision cost me now, and what might it give me later?
Am I calm enough to decide, or do I need food, sleep, rest, advice or perspective first?
Who do I actually need to speak to, and who do I not need to involve?
And finally: does this feel like a clear yes?
Because the best decisions aren’t made from a panicked or stressed state. They are made when we slow down, develop true clarity and make sure they are aligned with the life that we really want.
Written by Emilie West
Want to change roles? Not sure how to secure your dream job?
Take my 'Dream Job Readiness Quiz', to find out where you are now and what steps you need to take next to secure your next role.
